The working papers below are stored in .PDF files which can be
viewed on your screen and printed using the Adobe
- Carbon Pricing: Lessons from Experience November, 2011.
Abstract:Although programs to control climate change based upon pricing carbon
are relatively new, programs to price pollution more generally are not. Various forms
of emissions trading and pollution taxes or charges have been around since at least the late 1960s.
Both types of programs provide a wealth of experience from which to draw insights on how well
these programs work, and how the context matters. The experience with these programs also sheds
considerable light on the consequences of design choices, given the vast array of available options.
This brief survey is designed to summarize some of the chief lessons that can be drawn from this experience.
- Identifying the Sources of Maine's Dramatic Decline in Carbon Emissions Since 2005 December, 2011.
Abstract:According to data from the Maine Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), during the period 2005-2009 Maine CO2 emissions from the combustion of fossil fuels have dropped 21.8%. To put that into context the national cap-and-trade legislation seeks to achieve a 17-20% reduction from 2005 by 2020. Maine has almost hit that target 12 years early.
What were the sources of that decline? What roles do the recession, energy efficiency and conservation and fuel substitution play? In this memo I use the available data to provide some answers to those questions for the 2005-2009 period, a period that covers a bit over 2/3 of that reduction.
- The Tradable-Permits Approach to Protecting the Commons:
Lessons for Climate Change OXFORD REVIEW OF
ECONOMIC POLICY, VOL. 19, NO. 3, PP. 400-419 2003
Abstract:Tradable-permit approaches for rationing access
to the commons have been applied to many different types of
resources in many different countries. This essay reviews the
experience to draw together what we have learned about tradable
permits in practice that might offer some useful insights for the
implementation of the tradable-permit mechanisms that are part of
the Kyoto Protocol.
Tradable Permits Approach to Protecting the Commons: What Have We
Learned? (Written for National Research Council's
Institutions for Managing the Commons Project.)
Abstract: In this essay I review the experience with
three main applications of tradable permit systems: air pollution
control, water supply and fisheries management.Folowing a brief
summary of the theory behind these programs and both the economic
and environmental consequences anticipated by this theory, some
brief points of comparison are made with other competing and/or
complementary formal public policy strategies such as
environmental taxes and legal regulation. The essay proceeds with
a description of the common elements these programs share and the
design questions posed by the approach. These include the setting
of the limit on access, the initial allocation of rights,
transferability rules (both among participants and across time) as
well as procedures for monitoring and enforcement. It continues by
examining how these design questions have been answered by the air
pollution, fishery and water supply applications and how the
answers have evolved over time. This evolution has been influenced
by changing technology, increased familiarity with the system and
a desire to respond to some of the controversies surrounding the
use of these approaches. The penultimate section examines the hard
evidence on the economic and environmental consequences of
adopting these approaches. The final section draws together some
tentative lessons that can be drawn from this experience.
the Community: Information Strategies for Pollution Control
(Written for the Frontiers of Environmental Economics
Conference, Airlie House, Virginia, October 23-25, 1998.
Co-authored with David Wheeler, Lead Economist, Development
Research Group, World Bank.)
Abstract: Disclosure strategies, which involve public
and/or private attempts to increase the availability of
information on pollution, form the basis for what some have called
the third wave in pollution control policy (after legal
regulation--the first wave--and market-based instruments --the
second wave). While these strategies have become commonplace in
natural resource settings (forest certification programs, for
example), they are less familiar in a pollution control context.
Yet both the research on, and experience with, this approach is
now growing in both OECD and developing countries. This paper
reviews what we know and don't know about the use of disclosure
strategies to control pollution. (172K)
Permit Approaches to Pollution Control: Faustian Bargain or
Paradise Regained? (Written for Kaplowitz, M.D., ed. 1999.
Property Rights, Economics, and the Environment. Stamford, CT: JAI
Abstract: The idea of using the market to protect the
environment has become almost a fad in U. S.policy circles and it
has already spread to Latin America, Africa and the Far East. In
this essay my objective is to trace the evolution of one
significant component of this evolution, the use of tradable
permits to control air pollution, from its earliest inception to
recent developments. This evolution is used to show how the
programs have changed over time in response to both changing
circumstances and the lessons derived from the successes and
failures of earlier experiences. (168K)
Abstract: During December, 1997 the Kyoto Protocol
authorized an emissions trading approach to controlling greenhouse
gases (in Article 17), but left the implementation details up to
subsequent meetings. The UNFCCC Secretariat asked the United
Nations Conference on Trade and Development to commission a
backround report on how this program could be implemented as a
means of facilitating the negotiation process. This is the UNCTAD
report. Written collaboratively by Michael Grubb, Axel Michaelowa,
Byron Swift, Tom Tietenberg, ZhongXiang Zhang and Frank T. Joshua,
a draft of this report was presented at the Bonn meetings and the
final report was presented at the Buenos Aires meetings in
November, 1998. (340K)
Issues Seeking Research Answers (Written for the
Conference On Research Frontiers In GHG Emissions Trading,
Resources for the Future, Inc., Washington, DC, January 15, 1999)
Abstract: This report summarizes the author's sense of
major research issues associated with implementing Article 17 of
the Kyoto Protocol. (112K)
Abstract: This paper explores the special problems faced
in the management of environmental resources, paying particular
attention to valuation of ecosystem services, externalities,
uncertainty and the nonlinearities characteristic of complex
adaptive, highly interconnected systems. Through consideration of
case studies drawn from the management of lake and mangrove
ecosystems, it analyzes the challenges, suggests approaches to
their resolution, and endeavors to derive principles that
may guide management more generally. Written collaboratively by
Kenneth Arrow, Gretchen Daily, Partha Dasgupta, Simon Levin,
Karl-Göran Mäler, Eric Maskin, David Starrett, Thomas
Sterner and Tom Tietenberg, this report summarizes the results of
a Beijer Institute Workshop on Institutions for Managing
Ecological Services, Washington DC, April 11-12, 1999.
Introduction to The Evolution of Emissions Trading: Theoretical
Foundations and Design Considerations
Abstract: This paper will be published as the editor's
introduction to the first volume of a two-volume collection of
previously published articles. The volumes will be published in
the Environmental Economics Reference Series of Ashgate Press.
While the first volume focuses on the evolution of the theoretical
and design considerations, the second volume focuses more on the
empirical research and actual implementation experience.